• Spread the love

    CELEBRATING BUFFALO TOGETHER
    #totallybuffalo

    CELEBRATING BUFFALO TOGETHER
    #TOTALLY BUFFALO

 

More than 4000 of you voted and your favorite Ice Cream Shop is…. Amsdell Ice Cream in Hamburg

Spread the love

More than 4000 of you took the time to take our poll and here’s how you voted..

 

Amsdell Ice Cream, Hamburg – 1,781 votes

Main Street Ice Cream, Hamburg – 1,592 votes

Pink Cow Ice Cream, Alden – 722 votes

That makes Amsdell Ice Cream the Totally Best!

 

In case you’re wondering how we got here:

We posted an informal poll on Facebook asking folks for their favorite ice cream shop. We received 550 responses and took the top 3!

 

Congrats to Amsdell, Main Street and Pink Cow.

We were planning on writing a feature about the winner, but we are so impressed by all three that we will share a feature story about each one! Stay tuned.  Thank you to everyone who took the poll!

 

 

So… what makes Amsdell so super? Read on…

Amsdell Ice Cream is Totally The Best according to our readers! So what makes them so SUPER?

 

 

Mary Friona

Trackback from your site.

Mary Friona

Following my heart with my husband and four daughters. An Emmy Award winning journalist lucky enough to work in television & radio for 20 years - seeing wonderful places, meeting great people and telling their stories.

Comments (13)

  • Avatar

    Denise

    |

    Why can you only vote once???

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Nancy

    |

    All 3 so far away . Never been to any . No northtown ice cream was nominated ? I guess I missed the chance to nominate !

    Reply

    • Avatar

      Mary Schroeder

      |

      Disappointing. As usual, the northtowns are not considered Buffalo enough.

      Reply

      • Avatar

        Melissa

        |

        lol.. you should take a day trip out to Amsdell and try it…then you’ll understand…

        Reply

  • Avatar

    Heidi lynn

    |

    Lake Effect Ice Cream ? in Lockport should be nominated! They are homemade creative ice cream flavors that are out of this world!

    Reply

    • Avatar

      Sara

      |

      Main Street Ice Cream (which is on the list) in the Village of Hamburg makes their own homemade ice creams, their own novelties, ice cream cakes/pies, their own homemade waffle cones/bowls, they have amazing custard and both indoor and outside seating and so clean. Amazing

      Reply

      • Avatar

        Patricia

        |

        Yep, they should have won. They are the best.

        Reply

  • Avatar

    Jamie

    |

    Vote for HOMEMADE ice cream! Main St Ice Cream Hamburg :)!

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Linda

    |

    Good ivecream and very friendly

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Nicole

    |

    Guess the north towns don’t count! Disappointed!

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Doris Heuer

    |

    Mainstream Ice cream is perfect for Hamburg, NY.
    With all the the business has to offer.
    It’s been a great asset to the town.
    The growth & improvemets is a definite addition & jobs for the youth is a plus… Congrats! You are a winner for where your business is

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Maxine Poburn

    |

    Glad to help thank you very kindly

    Reply

Leave a comment